ABSTRACT
Objective: This paper analyzed the present clinical researches of traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) in the treatment of heart failure caused by coronary heart disease and discusses the ideas and methods of evidence-based optimization. Methods: PubMed, EMBASE, Cochrane Library, CNKI, WanFang, VIP and CBM were searched to screen the clinical studies of TCM for treating heart failure caused by coronary heart disease. The problems and solutions were discussed by evaluating the risk of bias of the studies and analyzing the outcomes compared with the Cochrane systematic reviews of chronic heart failure. Results: A total of 32 clinical researches were included and the methodological quality of the studies was generally low. In addition, few studies assessed the endpoint events, mortality and readmission, as the primary outcomes in their trials, which is significantly different from the outcomes concerned in the Cochrane systematic reviews. Conclusion: It is really critical to improve the methodological quality of the trials and to choose the endpoint events as the primary outcomes in the evidence-based optimization of the prevention and treatment of TCM for heart failure caused by coronary heart disease Chinese medicine.
ABSTRACT
Objective: To summarize the clinical effects of Shuxuening Injection on diseases and evaluate the quality of evidence to provide reference for the clinical application of Shuxuening Injection. Methods: Journal articles and conference papers were retrieved from the databases CNKI, Wanfang, VIP, CBM, EMbase, Pubmed and Cochrane with thematic word"Shuxuening"in Chinese and English, then all forms of clinical studies were screened and the disease types and frequency were analyzed, the dominant disease types of Shuxuening Injection were identified. Futhermore, RCT was extracted, and the literature quality was graded using the cochrane manual recommendation method, and its effectiveness and safety were evaluated. Results: All clinical research results show that Shuxuening Injection to treat disease with as many as 74 kinds of varieties, mainly circulation system disease and neural system disease, followed by endocrine disease, respiratory disease, scattered remaining research in ten other system diseases. These researches appeared with the highest frequency of the three diseases were cerebral infarction and its aftermath, angina pectoris and coronary heart disease, diabetes mellitus and its complication. A total of 337 RCT articles were included, all of which were of poor quality. In general, the efficiency of Shuxuening Injection treatment group was significantly higher than that of the control group, with a total efficiency of 84.48％. There were 21.96％ references to adverse reactions, but all of them were minor adverse reactions, such as pruritus, which generally got better by itself or after treatment. Conclusion:Shuxuening Injection has a wide range of clinical application and remarkable effect, especially for the ischemic diseases of cardiovascular and cerebrovascular diseases with good efficacy, less adverse reactions and safety. However, the quality of evidence is generally poor, which needs further study.